Pros:
Playmaking Ability: Josh Reynolds has demonstrated his ability to make plays on the field consistently. Despite occasional drops, his overall track record as a playmaker is solid.
Consistent First Downs: In the 2023 season, Reynolds caught 32 passes for first downs out of his total 40 receptions. This reliability in moving the chains is valuable for sustaining offensive drives.
Explosive Plays: Reynolds contributed significantly with 17 catches for 20 yards or more, showcasing his capability to stretch the field and create explosive plays.
Rapport with Jared Goff: Reynolds shares a strong rapport with Lions quarterback Jared Goff, having played together in both Los Angeles and Detroit. This established chemistry and trust can enhance their on-field connection.
Cons:
Limited Growth Potential: At 28 years old, Reynolds may have already reached his ceiling as a player. While he’s been successful in the NFL, there may not be much room for further growth or development.
Opportunity Cost: While Reynolds is a reliable option, the Lions may consider whether allocating funds to him prevents them from pursuing higher-ceiling players or younger talents who can offer similar production.
Conclusion:
Considering Reynolds’ proven ability to contribute positively on the field, his familiarity with Jared Goff, and his knack for making crucial plays, re-signing him would be a sensible move for the Lions. While there may be other options available, Reynolds’ existing chemistry with Goff and his track record of reliability make him a valuable asset worth retaining. Unless the Lions identify a significantly superior alternative, bringing back Reynolds should be a priority for the team’s offseason plans.